Tax-Managed Long/Short Is Accessible via Multiple Vehicles

An increasingly popular strategy comes in more structures than a traditional SMA.

Tax-managed long/short strategies are among the fastest-growing solutions available to investors today. By some estimates, industry assets have grown to roughly $170 billion,1 with the majority of that raised in the last three years. Investors have typically accessed these strategies through Separately Managed Accounts (SMAs). Given increased volume, however, some retail custodians have paused on new account openings and/or limited SMA access with higher minimums and restrictions on leverage. We believe it’s useful to understand the other vehicles that can deliver access.

Same Strategy, Different Wrapper

Tax-managed long/short is commonly offered through three structures: SMAs (as noted), comingled limited partnerships (LPs) and Series Limited Liability Companies (Series LLCs). All three have the same approach: invest to benefit from equity advances (long) and declines (shorts) in order to seek pre-tax alpha over the benchmark, while harvesting losses and deferring capital gains to potentially improve after-tax outcomes. Typically, the strategy does not change, but the wrapper does.

SMAs: Emphasis on Customization

Investors have widely adopted SMAs for multiple reasons. Funded with cash and securities, an SMA directly owns long and short positions through a custodian, which can offer daily liquidity, IRS Form 1099 reporting, and customizable leverage, benchmarks and investment restrictions. There are no loss limitations on an SMA, which means that investors may be able to realize losses in excess of the original cost basis, helping defer taxes into the future and benefiting from compounded tax savings.

The trade-offs: Access to SMAs varies by custodian and has been evolving quickly, with differing minimums, leverage choices and overall availability, making access to SMAs potentially unreliable. In addition, retail custodians set financing rates (e.g., on borrowed shares), which may be higher than those applied to institutions.

LPs: Simplicity and Negotiated Financing

A comingled LP commonly accepts cash funding only and offers liquidity on a set frequency (e.g., monthly) for cash redemptions. Investors receive Form K-1 tax reporting, and the trading within the LP is managed through a traditional prime broker. Having an asset manager negotiate financing costs at the LP level with a traditional prime broker can result in lower financing costs for the LP than for individual SMAs managed with a retail custodian. Also, partnership units may be eligible for a step-up in basis, helping to simplify the estate planning process.

The trade-offs: Under IRS rules, losses beyond a partner’s at-risk amount (cost basis) are suspended and carried forward. Leverage and benchmarks are set at the LP level. Because the investor holds a single partnership unit rather than the underlying securities, there are no in-kind redemptions. That said, a portfolio manager’s thoughtful approach to managing partnership units may help mitigate the capital gains impact of other partners’ flows through their LP accounting.

Series LLCs: Flexibility and Cost Benefits With Higher Minimums

A Series LLC is an institutionally managed vehicle that can offer individual investors the benefits of both an LP and an SMA. Similar to an LP, the manager can work with providers and a traditional prime broker to negotiate costs on behalf of an institutional mandate. The individual investor design can be similar to an SMA, allowing customization of leverage target, benchmark and restrictions, as well as in-kind funding or redemptions.

This structure offers Form 1099 tax reporting and series-level terms for liquidity. Redemptions can be tax-managed, and the series can transition to long-only at the investor’s request. Financing costs and operating expenses may be negotiated, potentially resulting in lower overall costs than a retail SMA.

The trade-offs: These vehicles generally have higher investment minimums, often in excess of $10 million, and are viewed by the investor as a single line item rather than granting individual stock transparency.

How to Choose

Selecting among these vehicles may involve an array of considerations:

  • Do you need to fund an investment with existing securities, or only cash?
  • Do you need a customized benchmark or restrictions?
  • Can you work with K-1 reporting and accept at-risk loss limits?
  • Is monthly liquidity acceptable, or do you need daily access?
  • What is your investable size?

Takeaway

In our view, tax-efficient long/short disciplines can offer significant advantages in seeking risk-adjusted alpha while limiting the return drag often created by portfolio taxation. However, the vehicle you choose to house such a strategy may differ based on practical considerations; ideally that choice is made by investors in close consultation with their advisory team and tax counsel.

 

Long/Short Vehicles at a Glance

Feature SMA Comingled LP Series LLC
Funding Cash and securities Cash only Cash and securities
Tax reporting 1099 K-1 1099
Loss limitations None Suspended above at-risk amount, carried forward None
Liquidity Daily Set at fund level Set by manager
Leverage and benchmark Customizable Set at fund level Customizable
Restrictions Customizable None Customizable
Holdings Direct long and short securities Single partnership unit Single line-item ownership
Partial redemptions Tax-efficient; can move to long-only N/A Tax-efficient, can move to long-only
Financing cost Set by custodian; retail rates Negotiated by manager; institutional rates Negotiated by manager; institutional rates

Source: Neuberger.

Subscribe

Timely insights, delivered to you

Get perspectives that help you navigate today’s markets.