As product innovations and regulation have removed barriers to entry, we assess the potential benefits for DC schemes of investing into private equity.

The private equity asset class has long been recognised for its appealing risk/return characteristics, particularly over the long-term investment horizon afforded to pension investors. However, inclusion in defined contribution plans in the UK market has often been limited by structural considerations such as fee-cap, regulation, liquidity and other factors. As product innovations reduce such barriers, however, we believe it’s time for defined contribution (DC) schemes to take a fresh look at the asset class.

In this article, we present a hypothetical study to illustrate the potential impact on asset accumulation of including private equity in a multi-asset solution, and how that affects the level of income that can be bought at retirement. We also highlight the different investment management approaches, and therefore considerations for DC schemes in choosing an investment partner.

Executive Summary

  • We modelled two hypothetical DC portfolios with a 40-year glide path.
  • One portfolio includes only traditional equities, while the other included an allocation to private equity, substituting part of the traditional equity allocation.
  • The higher risk-adjusted return profile of private equity investments improve not only mean return, but also, in a Monte Carlo simulation, the range of hypothetical portfolio returns.
  • These potential advantages would more than overcome the increased fees associated with the addition of private equity.
  • The resulting higher level of wealth-accumulation potential allows for the purchase of a larger annuity stream, increasing potential retirement income.

ADDING PRIVATE EQUITY ENHANCES HYPOTHETICAL OUTCOMES

Median, 10th and 90th percentile outcomes from 10,000 hypothetical return simulations for portfolios with and without private equity

Annualized return and volatility of fixed income portfolios

Source: Neuberger Berman. See figure 1 for the starting asset allocations and glide path allocations for both portfolios. The projections or other information generated by this analysis regarding the likelihood of various investment outcomes are hypothetical in nature, do not reflect actual investment results and are not guarantees of future results. These hypothetical returns are used for discussion purposes only and are not intended to represent, and should not be construed to represent, predictions of future rates of return. Actual returns may vary significantly. Our assumptions are subject to change without notice. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. See additional disclosures at the end of the downloadable paper.